Another big loss for Western Australia


Newly published shocking results after a long-wait senate count revealed that Greens Senator Scott Ludlam will not be representing the largest state in Australia (ABC News 2013), giving a lead of what is estimated to be a mere 14 votes to Zhenya Wang, a member of the Palmers United Party (PUP).

This marks another big loss for Western Australians – this time not in AFL, but in the senate. Western Australians had the privilege to vote for one of the best-spoken and vision-orientated politicians in the senate, who could present a real alternative to the main political parties, but somehow this choice has slipped through the system. This still comes as a big surprise, despite the apparent swing to the right nationally, at least for three reasons:

Firstly, Scott Ludlam has gained a wide popularity in Western Australia not only during his recent campaign, but also due to his long-term vision for Western Australia, as a solar state and by being well-connected to the progressive parts of the society in the state. On the contrary, Zhenya Wang has not been visible in any debates or political campaigns.

Secondly, because the lead of Senator Ludlam was confirmed until 88.6 % of the votes and preferences were counted, while the candidate for Palmers United party was not in the provisionally elected senators. Moreover, the Greens had almost twice the votes (124,268) than the Palmers United Party (65,511) or 9.8 % (Greens) as oppposed to 5 % (PUP) (ABC 2013).

Thirdly, it is surprising that the preferential system can allow for a virtually unknown person to represent the fastest growing and the largest state of Australia, while a well-placed politician in the community and in the political arena cannot.

The most obvious resolution to the problem is re-counting of the preferences. This is essential, not only for ensuring that Australia has the right people in the senate, but also that those, who are elected, have the pride of being legitimately elected, which at the moment they don’t and can’t claim to have.

Even in soccer, when the score is even, there are penalties to determine the winner.


ABC News, 2013, “Palmer United’s Zhenya Wang to represent WA in the Senate; Greens’ Scott Ludlam loses seat”, 2nd October 2013 accessed from on 2nd October 2013.

ABC, 2013, Senate Results accessed from on 2nd October 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s